Related Vacation Book Subjects: Iowa
More Pages: Scott Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100
Books to read if you're planning a vacation in "Scott", sorted by average review score:

Successology: The Science of Success
Published in Paperback by 1stCo Books (16 October, 2001)
Author: Scott Rogers
Average review score:

An inspirational plan for success!
Successoloy, is by far the most powerful and comprehensive plan for success I have ever encountered. Scott Rogers has managed to create a book that addresses both the personal and business side of an individual's life. With humor and an easy style of writing, Successology, teaches one to evaluate who you really are, what one projects to others, and then how one is perceived. The book is filled with tips, as well as, interactive worksheets in the form of questions and quizzes. He concludes the book with a "Success Formula" that is truly brilliant!

As a side note, after reading this book, I had an opportunity to attend one of Mr. Roger's seminars. The book can only be surpassed by his live presentation of "The Science of Success". He truly personifies all the lessons he so cleverly teaches. His wit and wisdom are inspirational. This is a must read!

Amazing
I was amazed when I read Successology. Firstly the style of writing was narrative and I felt like I was listening to someone chat to me - it was so user friendly. The contents of the book were so insightful, useful, and easily applicable. I realized quickly that this book held the secrets to my own success. By applying the ideas contained within its pages I have already seen a dramatic improvement in my life, in my attitude, and in my outlook. I am treating myself differently and in turn I am being treated much better by colleagues, and by friends and family.

I am so surprised that this book has not made it on to the likes of Oprah or the news shows (Successology is a MUST read for any sales person, manager, or just someone looking to be successful)...it really is innovative, thought provoking and in addition, it changes ones outlook on other self help books.

Successology does not ask you to spend any money (so that's a plus to begin with), it does not make wild promises, it just delivers what it says - a scientific approach to success which can be gained by anyone. The book is crammed packed with quotes, self tests, stories, ideas, theoretical analysis, and even has a website dedicated to it.

I would reccomend this book to everyone and indeed, I am going to be buying this book for all my colleagues.

Simply, this book is unbelievable until you actually read it. I think it will eventually rank as one of the all time greats in self help guides.

The Best Book On Success I Have Read
Scott Rogers' book on Success amazed me. This is the best book on the topic that I have seen to date. Whether you want to be the best in your field or simply the best you can be--Successology will give you the information you need to become a complete person--something we should all strive to be.

I particularly liked Scott's compelling THREE YOU perspective. It has helped me focus on my image--how I am perceived by others and how I can impact how others perceive me. All of us have hopes and dreams...Scott Rogers' book has helped me believe that I can attain my dreams by using the principles of success he's outlined in a simple format.

If there is a better written approach to success in life I would like to read it! This book is a must-have for anyone looking to achieve self-actualization. Furthermore, the book's conversational tone makes it easy to read and digest. I highly recommend it!


Swing : Third Ear - The Essential Listening Companion
Published in Paperback by Backbeat Books (15 April, 2000)
Author: Scott Yanow
Average review score:

Ace bunny killer!!
Scott Yanow, the editor of the "All Music Guide To Jazz," is probably one of the most readable jazz critics around. Here he concentrates on the music all the kids were talking about, that crazy little thing called swing. As ever, his style is clear and compact, and the breadth of his knowledge impressive. Yanow covers all the bases: the big bandleaders, the important musicians (broken down by type of instrument) and even a section on composers and arrangers. Even when he's talking about unfamiliar artists, he knows how to stir your curiousity (Cab Calloway had a famous older sister...!?), and the book has a lot to offer to a wide variety of readers. Hundreds of albums are rated on a 1 to 10 scale, and if anything Yanow is a little more charitable here than in his "AMG Jazz" reviews... He's particularly kind to the dozens of retro-swing acts that have sprouted up in recent years...but at least he had the good sense to knock the Cherry Poppin' Daddies down to size!

Swing
Swing takes readers into a world that few of us know. Yanow's research is flawless and his writer's voice is full of respect for the rich history of the jazz world. Even novices will enjoy this book. It is the standard for all other jazz books.

An almost perfect buyer's guide to Swing Music
This is a truly valuable book. Far, Far better than the Musichound Swing book. Unlike that book, which had several different reviewers, Scott Yanow is the only reviewer of selections in this book which makes for a much more even assessment of Swing Recordings. Yanow gives a brief history of Swing and gives the reader excellent bios of the musicians. Yanow also gives very good coverage to today's retro swing music, which, as Yanow points out, is often dismissed as fad by the mass media, many Jazz fans and Jazz magazines. His reviews of the new bands are honest and fair, unlike the Musichound book which, for the most part, seemed so have the view that Old=Good and New=Bad. His recomendations for each artist are perfect in almost all cases. I disagreed with only a few of his selections and reviews. The only complaint I have is a relatively minor one. He virtually ignores one of the greatest Swing acts, The Andrews Sisters. He includea a short bio and acknowledges their popularity, but he doesn't even recommend one CD for the trio. Surely, Mr. Yanow doesn't think the sisters are that terrible! This is really the only omission that I objected to. With the overwhelming selection of CDs to choose from, Scott Yanow's 'Swing' points out the very best selections and will help you to separate the good collections from the not-so-good collections.


Tactile Values
Published in Paperback by New Issues Pr Poetry Series (15 October, 2000)
Author: Mark Scott
Average review score:

Buy this book.
Scott's poems come at you like a great jazz line: at once controlled and extemporized; modulating, surprising, and honest --ever honest. You hear the poems at first reading and again when they repeat in your inner ear.

A strong work throughout
A searing book of poems. Honest and rigorous, with a sensibility serene enough to listen to the shadows, the steady music directing within and without.

A stunning collection. A small triumph of integrity and grace.

Gentle caresses; startling blows.
Mark Scott's words refuse to lie cold and aloof on the page. They rise and fall as inflections of voice, as pulses of action, as currents of feeling that leap across space to encircle the reader in a compelling embrace of memorable imagery, of imaginative memory. Scott takes everything personally - in the welcome sense of making even the abstract, intimate, and the intangible, concrete. These poems involve the reader not as a distanced spectator but as a confidante, a collaborator, a hands-on conspirator in wresting beauty from life's closely observed beasts.

The volume's title describes the poet's project: to touch and be touched (and sometimes to exorcise unwanted touch). Scott's ingenious command of expression relays with palpable force his uncommon perceptions of our common vocations: our journeys through the thickets of love, loss, ambition, disappointment, longing; from the limpidness of childhood to the culpabilities of adulthood. Always, an imprint is scored - and, like the touch of an absent lover, viscerally felt long afterward.


Tail Talk
Published in Paperback by 1stBooks Library (February, 2003)
Authors: Lucile E. Manley and Mary E. Scott
Average review score:

The book is "Tail Talk" by Lucile E. Manley, and my review
If you are a person who has decided that cats should not be a part of your life, this book will confirm all the reasons for your decision. If you are a cat lover, you will relate to all the frustrations, demands and delights of being owned by a cat (especially a French-speaking one). Thoroughly entertaining,funny, and imaginative with delightful illustrations, Tail Talk will make a fine gift to anyone, regardless of feline bias.

Cat lover or not, you'll laugh out loud
Tail Talk is a witty recounting of a relationship that begins when the author arrives fresh from the city with plans to grow flowers and vegetables which the gophers think are delicious. Manley buys a $1900 fence at the advice of her neighbor and looks for a cat to kill the gophers. She doesn't really want a cat. They are lots of trouble, tearing up the upholstery, throwing up on the rug in front of company and shedding hair all over the house. But there are those gophers, so she goes to an animal shelter and falls in love with a fifteen pound orange fur ball she names Barbara.

The book tells of the adjustments necessary to live with a cat. How do you adjust to a cat with gourmet tastes who loves the food one day and bats it off the dish and tries to bury it the next? How do you teach the cat to use the cat scratcher rather than your furniture? "Demonstrate," says Lucile, "with your own nails. My fingernails look great. I don't have to trim them half as often as I used to." And then there is the name Barbara for a male cat. This causes much stress for the veterinarian.

Cat lover or not, you will find these stories both amusing and hysterically funny and will want to read them aloud to your friends. As far as I can tell, the gophers are still enjoying the garden.

A Cat With an Attitude
TAIL TALK by Lucile E. Manley
Illustrated by Mary E. Scott

Highly Recommended. Give it to a friend. Take a break from world turmoil and personal worries; read this book. If it doesn't make you laugh out loud, you are beyond hope.

Adoption of a cat can be a life-altering experience. Lucile Manley, avid gardener, wants a cat to eliminate gophers from her garden, provide warm, furry companionship, and never scratch the furniture. A cat to fill her "owner's" needs. Barbara Orange Cat has a different agenda.

In twenty delightful chapters, enchanced by Mary E. Scott's hilarious illustrations, Manley describes life with Barbara. The way Barbara uses her tail to communicate, her early morning demands for food (but only certain food), her needs in proper accomodations and equipment, including a Zen Garden litter-box, and her complete disdain for gopher hunting--all strengthen the bond between cat and human--and raise questions as to which is superior. Barbara remains Barbara Orange Cat, even though the Vet points out that she is a male cat.

Read TAIL TALK for fun and understanding. Manley says, "There's a lot to be learned from living with a cat." She offers a list of directions for selecting a cat at the animal shelter, then adds, "If your first glance at a whiskered, furry face tears out your heart, forget all of the above... you have found your very own personal cat."


Taunton Workshop Classics Set: The Workbench Book, the Toolbox Book, the Workshop Book
Published in Paperback by Taunton Press (September, 1998)
Authors: Scott Landis and Jim Tolpin
Average review score:

Excellent Gift Material
These volumes are an excellent choice for gift giving, of interest to both the woodworker and his family. Beautiful to look at and thumb through, they appeal to anyone with a passing interest in how things are made or how to build functional and aesthetic work spaces. They have an historical flare for the non-craftsman and are full of good ideas for the woodworker.

Ideas Galore
These three books have given me more ideas and inspiration about setting up shop than any others. Seeing how others have solved working and storage problems in detail automatically suggests how their solutions can be adapted to a particular situation. If you look past the project pictures in magazines to see the shop of the author you will enjoy these books immensely.

This is an incredible set of great ideas.
I just received the three piece Taunton Workshop Classics Set as a Christmas gift. I love it. The workbench book is my favorite so far. It has detailed discussions of several "classic" workbenches (Of Shaker and psuedo scandinavian design) including mearsured drawings. But the discussions of why the various woodworkers built their benches the way they did is of even more interest. Also, being a beginning luthier myself (Luthier = guitar builder) I enjoyed the special lutherie sections in both the workbench book and the workshop book. I would highly suggest this series for any serious woodworker. You'll spend a lot of late nights by the fire drooling over these fine toolboxes, workbenches and shops.


Thank You for the Flowers: Stories of Suspense & Imagination
Published in Paperback by Parkway Publishers, Inc. (01 September, 2000)
Author: Scott Nicholson
Average review score:

Everything a Collection Should be!
Scott Nicholson, author of the very successful The Red Church, first began his career writing short stories. This short story collection assembles some of his quieter, more affecting pieces. And what a collection it is! You will not find a single story that rings false in this book.

Two of the best pieces, The Boy Who Saw Fire and Thirst, are two stories set in a strange mythology Nicholson has created. These stories explain the reasons behind rain and wind and the sunset/sunrise. They fully display Scott's great imagination and his skill with words.

There are also many ghost stories in this book. Haunted is a traditional haunted house story (every author needs to have one!) and The Three-Dollar Corpse is a strange ghost tale set in a concentration camp. Then, there is also In The Heart of November a very poignant and sad love story set around a ghost.

These are only some of the good pieces. The great ones are the ones we should talk about. First, there is Kill Your Darlings, a great little story that borders satire about writers and where they get their ideas. There is also The Vampire Shortstop, a great vampire tale about a little boy who just wants to play baseball. The ending will leave you all choked up.

The one story I enjoyed most was Dead Air, about a radio dj who receives calls from a murderer. The story is simple but the characters so likeable and the dialog so witty that I found myself grinning through the whole thing.

This is a great collection to have in your personal library. Every story has its own voice and style. Scott will surely become a great name in horror fiction, so you should grab his debut before they're all gone.

No, Scott --- Thank you!
Thank You for the Flowers is a rare book-- a single author collection without a single wasted page --- Scott's voice varies enough from tale to tale to avoid the reader being about to get a firm grasp on his world view --- no way of telling what's coming from second guessing him.

The mood of the stories shifts as well, from disquieting glimpses into aspects of human behavior to straight up fantastic with an odd not-ammoral twist . . . Scott is not precisely a moralist --- He does have opinions about right and wrong, good and evil --- while the reader may not always agree with his opinion the integrity of his fiction is such that you go along for the ride.

One of the stories in this volume is on my list of best stories I've ever read ---- several of them are worth the price of the book.

This is Scott's first book --- I suspect that collectors should grab it now ---

Surreallistically thought-provoking
Thank You For The Flowers is an interesting blend of short stories containing subjects ranging from the initial loss of childhood innocence to stabs at spiritual role playing. These unusual perspectives provide insights into this author's twisted gatherings of thoughts derived from daily experiences.


Thunder Falls (Dinotopia, 6)
Published in Paperback by Random House Childrens Pub (December, 1996)
Authors: Scott Ciencin and James Dinotopia Gurney
Average review score:

thunder falls
Joseph and fleetfeet twoo friends were on a quest to find a map but when they got there somebody took it then they found out the mission was fake. I agree with the author when he did not go off the water fall becauyse he would have died irecommend it to dinosaur lovers

Thunder Falls
Joseph and Fleetfeet, Two friends were on a quest to find a map with wrong info but when they get there, Sombody took it . They tracked down the man that took it but he was in danger so they saved him and Brought the map back to their mentor but they found out that the quest was fake

The best Dinotopia series book!
This book is awsome! I've read it over 5 times and never get tired of it! With the amazing Thunder Falls and great description, it makes you want to be there! And the friendship between Joseph and Fleetfeet is really awsome, this book is a must-read.


Ticket to Ride
Published in Paperback by Quill (April, 1991)
Authors: Denny Somach, Kathleen Somach, Kevin Gunn, and Scott Muni
Average review score:

Scott Muni's radio interviews about (and with) the Beatles
"Ticket to Ride" was a radio show hosted by Scott Muni devoted entirely to the music and memory of the Beatles (remember the radio station in New York City that played nothing but Beatles music?). Muni was a New York radio mainstay for more than twenty years who was not only a disc jockey but a friend to the Beatles. "Ticket to Ride," the book, brings together photographs, rare Beatles memorabilia from Muni's personal collection, and, most importantly, the transcripts of interviews with those touched by the Beatles in important ways. This means musicians like Elton John, Jimmy Page, Sting, and the Rolling Stones talking about how the Beatles inspired their own careers. Then there are friends like Pete Best and Tommy Smothers, family like Yoko Ono and Julian Lennon, musical associates like Billy Preston and George Martin, and the Beatles themselves talking candidly about their lives and music. Muni writes the introduction, and the transcripts are edited by Denny Somach, Kathleen Somach, and Kevin Gunn. The order of these transcripts could not be characterized as chronological, but there is a general attempt to provide a sense of moving forward. An index would have been nice, so that if you want to read about the Beatles appearance on "The Ed Sullivan Show," Brian Epstein, or the recording sessions for "Let It Be," that it would be more by purpose than happenstance, but transcripts rarely get presented that way. So, basically what we have in "Ticket to Ride" is an expert interviewer talking with about four dozen famous names about the Beatles, including the most famous names (John, Paul, George and Ringo). These are essentially primary document and virtually every interview is an enjoyable and informative read. Warning: when you read the John Lennon interview be prepared to rummage through your music library to play the same songs that pop up during the conversation.

Enjoyed the ride.......
This book is perfect for Beatles fans of all ages. Based on the radio show that ran for seven years, it collected a lot of great stories. Should be reissued!

Fantastic! Should be re-issued.
The best compilation of stories on The Beatles. A must for any Beatle Fan. The book is based on the succesful Radio Show "Ticket to Ride"

This book should be re-issued.


Time Regained: A Guide to Proust (In Search of Lost Time , Vol 6)
Published in Paperback by Modern Library (March, 1999)
Authors: Marcel Proust, Andreas Mayor, Terence Kilmartin, D. J. Enright, Joanna Kilmartin, and C. K. Scott Moncrieff
Average review score:

A novel for all Time
In this final life's work of Proust on the theme of the passage of Time it's clear that the author is riper, near to death and concerned about the lasting impact of his writing. "Eternal duration is promised no more to men's works than to men." Yet there is so much beauty and substance and lyricism in his 4,300 pages clearly his volumes are, both individually and collectively, a masterwork for the ages. The novel seems more like an autobiography in which the names of persons and places have been changed to protect the innocent (and the gulity). Because of his theme, Marcel constantly returns to the events of his life to gain some semblance of understanding of them. In this volume he is concerned with the effect of the world war upon Paris. The familiar characters of Gilberte and Bloch happily emerge again to center stage and, as always, Charlus and Morel. Because of his failing health and self-exile from society, he must have known that he had little Time to tie up all the loose ends and that another volume would not be in the offing after this one. Indeed, he never lived to see this volume in print. By virtue of his failing health the pressing nature of his last years lend a poignancy to the themes of this volume so that it stands out among the other works when Time was full of budding possibilities and had not ultimately become a dreaded adversary. In this volume Proust picks up the leitmotifs that thread their way through this remarkable tapestry in his walks down various ways and he brings them all to a meaningful end. The story lines are surprisingly simple and easy to follow and there is so much enduring value in his masterfully articulated "impressions." I decided to commit Time a few months ago to read all of Proust's work --it was Time well spent. I can't encourage you enough to make a similar investment. The work is truly a Timeless masterpiece from one of the real geniuses of his day and through it Proust has justly earned his immortality, his worthy prominence among the best literary minds of all Time.

In Search of Madame Putbus' Maid
I attach this review of Proust's cycle of novels to the last novel in the cycle because things are calmer here than over at Swann's Way. The crowd here seems to have thinned out a little. Contrary to what some reveiwers claim, plenty happens in the seven novels comprising In Search of Lost Time. Plenty happens, but it happens "over time" - as in real life. In "Marcel's" case, it's a life during which the exalted are brought low and the base are exalted. Proust's novelistic enterprise, which early-on might be dismissed as nothing more than the effete self-absorption of a Parisian dilettante who's "not worth the rope to hang him" (as one character maintains in Vol. III), turns out, by the final volume, to be a good deal grittier than first appeared.

The choice of translation matters. The older, Moncrieff translation comes across as precious and sentimental, while the newer Mayor/Enright/Kilmartin edition seems less so. Compare the title Moncrieff chose, Remembrance of Things Past, (a phrase lifted out of Shakespeare's Sonnet 30) to the literally-translated title used in the newer edition: In Search of Lost Time. Also compare, "I would ask myself what o'clock it could be" (Moncrieff) with "I would ask myself what time it could be" (Enright). Though the differences may be minor, I had a much better experience with the newer translation.

The cycle of seven novels in six volumes takes considerable TIME to read. I spent the slack year between early retirement and late graduate school reading it. Thus, I modestly propose that every American who has not already done so should quit his or her job immediately and carefully read all seven novels before proceeding any further with thier lives. Not that I'm an enthusiast. My proposal follows from an opinion that we Americans need to spend more time thinking and less time doing. That way we'd do less harm. Even so, readers should be prepared for a certain Proustian indifference to minor matters of proportion. They may find a single sentence that occupies an entire page, or a single paragraph that goes on for eight pages. A chapter of 300 or more pages may be follwed by a chapter of 25 pages. "Marcel" may go on for fifteen pages about what he experiences while trying to remember a name that's on "the tip of his tongue." But if you don't enjoy lengthy examinations of inner experiencings, you probably shouldn't be reading Proust. There were also occasional long stretches of such drek that I wanted to gag. "Marcel's" sojourn with soldiers in Doncieres in Vol. III was one such. Readers must be prepared to simply forge ahead when encountering these. It gets better.

Which leads me to Vol. VI, Time Regained, a tour de force, without a doubt. If the "tea and madeleine" segment in Swann's Way forms the left bookend for In Search of Lost Time, Time Regained forms the right one. I wouldn't want to give too much away about Proust's final volume. William Empson claimed to have expected an apocalypse and accordingly lamented (or pretended to lament) the apparent insignificance of what Proust actually provided. I'd hate to give away more than Empson did, but I think that by the final volume "Marcel's" fruitless pursuit of Madame Putbus' maid has been abandoned at last. Even the face of Mme de Guermantes, admired by "Marcel" through seven novels, has begun to resemble "nougat" with traces of verdigris and fragmentary shell-work on which grew "a little growth of an indefinable character, smaller than a mistletoe berry and less transparent than a glass bead." Volume VI shows "Marcel" at his funniest, and most misanthropic, as attached as ever to his own follies, yet as quick as ever to dissect those of his friends - a decidedly tragic vision. It made the long read worthwhile. After I finished Time Regained I went back to Vol. I and began all over again.

Intimately beautiful in spite of reputation for grandeur.
Alright, so I'm a cheat. I never thought I'd get beyond admiring the bright spanking six volumes of A la recherche (3700 pages! Phew!) on my bookshelves, but when it was announced that Raul Ruiz had made a film of the last book, I seized my chance. Thanks to this brilliant edition you can, because at the end is an exhaustive guide to Proust, listing every character, historical person, place and theme of the whole work, so that just by referring regularly to this you quickly catch up with what's going on. Of course this isn't the same as living with characters and events through literature, but this volume is so amazing you can't fail to want to begin the whole thing and experience them from the start.

This is, as I expected, one of the most beautiful and exciting books I have ever read, as well as one of the most frustrating and irritating. What is most surprising, for a book claimed as one of the two greatest of the century, is how old-fashioned it is (compared to the still startlingly modern and socially relevant ULYSSES).

It has two types of narrative. One, about a young middle class boy who penetrates society, is a mixture of social comedy and tortured romance familiar to anyone who has read a great Victorian novel - there is the same social analysis of an outmoded caste, wide range of characters, poetic evocation of place.

The language, once you get used to the involved, elaborate sentences, is very accessible in a Jamesian kind of way, intricately psychological and analytical, yet supremely elegant and radiant, with a verve and lightness remarkable for such a heavy book.

The translation is, for once, remarkable - it can never be the original, I guess, but you rarely feel that you are getting only half the work like you usually do.

The second half is less satisfactory. As is appropriate to a book concerned with time, the book's forward progress is constantly impeded, by degressions, flashbacks, fastforwards, explanations. The book, like those of Anthony Powell (if you loved THE DANCE TO THE MUSIC OF TIME, you'll adore this) is less straight plotting, than a series of monumental set-pieces.

This novel is 450 pages long, but has only about three events - the narrator going back to the country to stay with friends; the first world war; a huge party. These are mini-novels in themselves and are extraordinary as social observation, character comedy and amusing incident, as well as profoundly moving meditations on the inexorable power of history and old age.

Imagine the narrator has a remote control as he is walking through the film of his life. He freezes the screen every three seconds and discusses in detail the tableaux vivants before him, bending time and experience back and forwards with ease as he does so.

In between these are ruminations on the art of writing. This is a remarkably self-reflexive book, the narrator suddenly starts talking about how he came to write it, what he intended to achieve and what tools he was going to use. The volume becomes less the conclusion of a vast work than the record of its inception; you have to go back then and read it again (believe me, 3700 pages won't seem enough).

This section, a book-length manifesto, is fascinating and thrilling, but also repetitive, difficult, frustrating, and sometimes obscure - it gets in the way of the brilliant descriptive passages - the meeting with Baron de Charlus is possibly the most extraordinary thing I have read, until the remarkable coup of the closing party, where people the narrator hasn't seen for years have grown horribly old and form a grotesque, funereal fancy dress party - you want him to shut up talking about Time and impressionism and get back to the fun.

Two other things: Evelyn Waugh was wrong - Proust is hilarious, both with subtle ironies and more obvious satiric abuse; with risible character traits and wider social events.

Secondly, the narrator is not some unbearable omnisicient know-all as those of Victorian novels - he is deeply unreliable - a prig, hypocrite, voyeur, homophobic, intolerant, puritan, snob, deeply contradictory and cripplingly ill; in earlier volumes he is apparently obsessional, jealous and brutal to the point of insanity. No wonder Nabokov adored him - he is, in his ravishingly aesthetic unreliability, the first Humbert.


Trout and Salmon of North America
Published in Hardcover by Free Press (24 September, 2002)
Authors: Robert J. Behnke, Joseph R. Tomelleri, Thomas McGuane, Donald S. Proebstel, and George Scott
Average review score:

Tomelleri and Behnke
This book is a 2002 collaboration between the most knowledgeable trout/salmon biologist and the best illustrator! Tomelleri is the all time out standing trout artist. There are several books out that attempt to do a similar compendium like 'Trout' by James Prosek which is also excellent, and a great addition to your library. But the synergy between Tomelleri and Behnke is unbeatable. It a sad description of sub species of Salmo lost forever, but does offer a ray of hope for some species. If you have any interest in N.A. Salmonids this is a must buy. It is written for the layman: no high level back ground in Ichthyology is needed to enjoy it. Buy it - you will not be disappointed.

Greatest fish book ever
This is the most interesting book in my collection. I am shocked that since this volume has become avaiable, only a single review has been submitted. Being a fisheries Ph.D student and long time salmonid fanatic, this is the book I've been waiting for my whole life.
The design of this volume is great. Have any of you ever looked at a book's layout? This masterpiece should be studied in a graphics design course.
I specialize in scientific illustration (black & white technical stuff). Much of my work has been published in Dr. Balon's: Environmental Biology of Fishes and I dare say I have an eye for what's good within this field. While Tomelleri's early salmonids (see Fishes of the South central USA) are okay at best, the ones featured in this book are out of this world. Strangely, he includes some of his earliest works(p.71, p.261). These must have been added for sentimental reasons and have little value being included with the otherwise superb lateral views.
I find it strange to see the reaction of people when I show them particular pictures from this book. They seem to get equal enjoyment from all the illustrations, mainly because of the flamboyent salmonid colors. No one picks up on the astounding progression in style/technique that Tomellerri has gone through over the years. Yet it is very evident indeed. No one has pointed out that while all the renderings are lovely, stuff like the pink salmon on p.43-45 represent the technical limit of what can be achieved with color pencil realism. My favorite? The Presidio trout on p. 121. I hate to say it, but the pictures (and book overall) are too good. Anyone can pick up a leica and enjoy its smooth mechanical functions but how many of us can appreciate the beauty of German industrial design and fine craftsmanship? This book suffers a similar fate. It will sell because we all love pretty trout, end of story.
I can't stop reading and looking at this book. I fall asleep next to it and in the morning, look through it some more. Our family collects antique books and my love for books extends into other fields as well. This is the greatest of all my prize posessions.
I enjoyed Dr. Benke's text. He is able to convey scientific information in a style that appeals to naturalists, fishermen and those of us within the sciences. I first came across his writings in the magazine Trout and like many of you, I fell in love with his AFS book on trout of western North America. Maybe the fact that I am fascinated by phenotypic plasticity and morphological variation within species has placed me in a situation to better appreciate what this book has tried to accomplish, but I hope not. I only wish that some of you can feel what I experienced when I first received my copy of Trout & Salmon of North America. This book beautifully articulates the complex and fascinating world of salmonids through stunning pictures and wonderful text.

An excellent introduction to North American salmonids
Dr. Behnke is one of the foremost authorities on the taxonomy of Salmonidae. I can think of no one who has done more to save fisheries management from the one-size-fits-all mindset that has dictated the stocking thousands of miles of streams containing healthy populations of native trout with non-native hatchery stocks of rainbow trout. The policy of planting poorly adapted (and often diseased) hatchery fish on top of healthy populations of native trout, caused the outright extinction or local extirpation of native subspecies and stocks of trout throughout the western United States and Canada. Many of these fish had unique life histories that enabled them to successfully exploit habitats that hatchery rainbows cannot successfully utilize (without the continuation of massive and expensive stocking programs). At the very least, they represent a diversity form and life history that would be impossible to replace with the limited gene pool available in hatchery strains. Many of these fish, such as the golden trouts, interior cutthroats, and redband rainbows are living jewels, breathtakingly beautiful and perfectly adapted to their respective environments. The loss of any of these remarkable fish would diminish any person who cares about our natural heritage.

Professional biologists, such as myself, may have wished for a little more technical information than the book contains, such as was available in his 1965 PhD Thesis, A Systematic Study of the Family Salmonidae with Special Reference to the Genus Salmo or his 1992 mongraph, Native Trout of Western North America. Dr. Behnke has published a continuing series of articles on salmonid taxonomy, distribution, and life histories in Trout, the journal of the Trout Unlimited organization. He has used these articles to bring the importance of preserving the diversity of life histories present in each species to the attention of anglers and managers throughout North America. Whether a population is a species, subspecies, 'race,' or 'stock' has little meaning from a management standpoint, if it displays unique life history traits that enable it to exploit habitat extremes or niches that are inaccessible to other populations or hatchery stocks. As with agricultural crops, the loss of wild genotypes can never be fully compensated for and adaptations to local environments make many of these stocks the only fish that can successfully maintain naturally reproducing populations adapted to local disease organisms and environmental conditions.

I was hoping the book would include appendices that described all of the new technical information available about the family Salmonidae. Instead the book is a wonderful publication for the general public, containing a though and highly readable description of the wonderful diversity of form and life history represented by North American salmonids. Combined with Joseph Tomelleri's incredibly detailed and lifelike representative illustrations, this is a welcome addition to the library of any angler or biologist.

In addition to his contributions to the establishment of saner management policies for native fish, Dr. Behnke described or collaborated in describing literally dozens of distinctive populations of salmonids. Many of these fish; such as the Sheepheaven Creek Redband, Humbolt River cutthroat, fine-spotted Snake River cutthroat, and Whitehorse cutthroat; were simply described as a new subspecies without assigning a subspecies name to them. Dr. Behnke generally only assigned new scientific names, where a species or subspecies designation was incorrect, and a prior name already existed. Hence, the Yellowstone cutthroat became Oncorhynchus clarki bouvieri instead of O. c. lewisi and the interior Columbia/Fraser River rainbow became O. mykiss gairdneri, rather than O. gairdneri. This brings me to one of my few quibbles about the book.

In the 1995 book, Many Rivers to Cross by M.R. Montgomery (a Boston Globe columnist), the author included the descriptive information from Dr. Behnke's monograph, Native Trout of Western North America, under the name Oncorhynchus clarki behnkei. I'm a fisheries biologist, rather than a taxonomist, but as I understand the process of naming a new species (or subspecies), the name should accompany a species account that includes a description of the species and information on the collection where the type (type specimen) is or will be deposited (perhaps Mr. Montgomery included all of Dr. Behnke's original description in his book and this is sufficient). This information is usually published in a journal or book (but I'm not sure if it has to be published by a professional taxonomist in a professional publication). The first name assigned has priority. If a non-professional can assign a name in any form of publication, then I believe that Ernest Schwiebert beat Mr. Montgomery to the punch by a couple of decades in his 1978 book, Trout, when he assigned the name Salmo carmichaeli (after a Wyoming tackle shop owner) to the Jackson Hole cutthroat and included an excellent illustration of a fine-spotted cutthroat from Blacktail Spring Creek in Wyoming. While its true that Schwiebert gave it species status, the same can be said of the rainbow trout, which was originally named Salmo gairdneri before it was reassigned the name Oncorhynchus mykiss gairdneri (gairdneri was assigned to the interior Columbia/Fraser River subspecies). Will some taxonomist please name a trout after Dr. Behnke?!! He certainly deserves the honor. It would be a nice gesture if a committee of taxonomists would decide which of Dr. Behnke's many unnamed subspecies of Oncorhynchus most deserves subspecies status and assign it the subspecies name, behnkei. The fine-spotted Snake River cutthroat seems like a fine fish to name after Dr. Behnke, but I'm sure any of the salmonids he has described over his long career would serve as a fine honor.


Related Vacation Book Subjects: Iowa
More Pages: Scott Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100